In the manner of an investigating judge, Greenaway carves out a frame within the image and shows us the theory of the accusation with many interviews with the events’ protagonists.
Analyzing these 30 clues, the director relates the political, economic, social and above all artistic context when the artist painted one of the four most-seen paintings in the world. Events that, however, could also seem to refer to current events.
Like all of the director’s films, Rembrandt’s J'accuse unfolds along various levels. There is the investigation of Rembrandt’s fall from grace caused by the powerful men who with his painting he wanted to accuse, as well as an important lesson on art history. Greenaway states that with the introduction of artificial light and the diffusion of mirrors, much light as well as many shadows and diverse perspectives emerged and the greatest painters of the era knew how to see them and convey their visions on canvas.
Greenway returns to his beginnings as a painter here and says he would like a cinema that is less textual and made up more of images, even though he begrudgingly admits that some of the biggest film hits of the recent years are based on literature, such as Harry Potter and Lord of the Rings. And he knows full well that he would never get to make a film if he were to present a producer with just four paintings.
Kicca D’Ercole cineuropa.org